T
tomtombp
Senior Member
Hungarian
- Dec 30, 2016
- #1
Best wishes for/in the new year
Is it in or for? For makes more sense to me as it's a wish for that period not a wish made in the new year. On the other hand, for is used for what we wish for.
I've seen both.
Also would you capitalize Best, Wishes, New and Year?
Last edited:
Englishmypassion
Banned
Nainital
India - Hindi
- Dec 30, 2016
- #2
It's "for", if you wish them to come true in the new year.
Andygc
Senior Member
Devon
British English
- Dec 30, 2016
- #3
tomtombp said:
On the other hand, for is used for what we wish for.
I don't understand why you say "on the other hand". You have correctly stated why we use "for". You want the wishes to happen: that is what you are wishing for.
By the way, you could make a New Year's resolution to include your subject text in your question so that the moderators have less work to do.
You could edit your post now.
T
tomtombp
Senior Member
Hungarian
- Dec 30, 2016
- #4
Thanks, I think "in" comes from "All the best in the new year".
Andygc said:
I don't understand why you say "on the other hand". You have correctly stated why we use "for". You want the wishes to happen: that is what you are wishing for.
I meant "for" is reserved for the wish itself not the period.
Andygc said:
By the way, you could make a New Year's resolution to include your subject text in your question so that the moderators have less work to do.
You could edit your post now.
Edited. Sorry about that.
Andygc
Senior Member
Devon
British English
- Dec 30, 2016
- #5
The wishes are being made now. They are for the New Year to be a good and happy one. "Best wishes" is a set phrase which means something along the lines of "I wish everything will be the best for you". If we are linking the wishes to an event, then "on" is normal. If we are linking the wishes to a period then it is "for".
Best wishes on your birthday. Best wishes on your wedding day. Best wishes for your new job. Best wishes for the new year.(I don't capitalize that, some do.)
siares
Senior Member
Slovak
- Dec 31, 2016
- #6
Andygc said:
If we are linking the wishes to an event, then "on" is normal. If we are linking the wishes to a period then it is "for".
What do you think of 'in' in I wish you the best in New Year?
I would prefer 'in' because I mean I want for the good to meet you in the course of a year.
Other threads: most prefer 'for' but say that 'in' is possible. Interprete_r said: "all the best in the new year" or "all the best for the New Year" DonnyB said: I would instinctively use "for" myself, but I don't think there's any difference in meaning, no. sound shift said: I could not say "All the best in the next year" or "All the best to the next year". Lis48 said: I would use in if it was one specific exam and with if I wasn´t sure how many different tests the exam consisted of.
DonnyB
Moderator Emeritus
Coventry, UK
English UK Southern Standard English
- Dec 31, 2016
- #7
siares said:
What do you think of 'in' in I wish you the best in New Year?
I would prefer 'in' because I mean I want for the good to meet you in the course of a year.Other threads: most prefer 'for' but say that 'in' is possible.
Most people in those threads that you you found seem to agree that "for" is the usual way of doing it: if you express the wish to the person now "for the New Year" then you're automatically projecting it forward to the duration of the coming year. As I said in my post, I don't think that using "in" alters the meaning.
siares
Senior Member
Slovak
- Dec 31, 2016
- #8
DonnyB said:
then you're automatically projecting it forward to the duration of the coming year.
Thank you. Is wishing 'good' grammatically different to wishing love, health, luck/success? I prefer the for-less version in the quote below, and that makes me want to use 'in' with NY.
PaulQ said:
Both are correct.
"Good luck tomorrow" = "I wish that/hope you will have good luck tomorrow"
"Good luck for tomorrow" = "In respect of the thing that will happen tomorrow, I wish/hope you have good luck at that time."
DonnyB
Moderator Emeritus
Coventry, UK
English UK Southern Standard English
- Dec 31, 2016
- #9
siares said:
Thank you. Is wishing 'good' grammatically different to wishing love, health, luck/success? I prefer the for-less version in the quote below, and that makes me want to use 'in' with NY.
It's the context (in the example you've given there it's a driving test) which makes that work without the "for". If someone had a series of exams next week, I could say "Good luck next week!"
I suppose you could say "Good luck next year" but unless it was linked to a particular event other than just a new year, then it would sound rather odd in my opinion.
siares
Senior Member
Slovak
- Dec 31, 2016
- #10
DonnyB said:
"Good luck next year" but unless it was linked to a particular event other than just a new year
Thank you, DonnyB. One last question - I didn't realise 'luck' must be linked to a specific situation, in my language there is only one word for luck/happiness - could you confirm for words which are not, below?
I wish you riches, good health and happiness in the new year.
I wish you riches, good health and happiness for the new year.
DonnyB
Moderator Emeritus
Coventry, UK
English UK Southern Standard English
- Dec 31, 2016
- #11
I don't think I've ever heard anybody say that, but I think "in" works better there.
Something like "good health", particularly, is something you'd experience in or during the coming year.
siares
Senior Member
Slovak
- Dec 31, 2016
- #12
DonnyB said:
I don't think I've ever heard anybody say that
Those are 'the best' things being wished!
Thank you, DonnyB, and I wish you the best (see above) for the New Year.
You must log in or register to reply here.